Annie goes to Valerie's apartment where she is staying with two other flight attendants named Carol and Leslie. In the surveillance van, Chris tells Gene and Ray about his date. He says that he had a couple of drinks and puked on his date while he tried to kiss her. Carol and Leslie arrive and are surprised to see Valerie. They ask Valerie/Annie where she has been. Valerie tells Carol that she was mugged. Valerie says that she didn't call because she was out of it. Valerie finds an envelope hidden in the ceiling panel. She sees that there is a date book with a flight scheduled for tomorrow highlighted. Sam calls Annie on the radio and tells her that she is doing a great job. Annie tells Sam that Valerie has a lot of posters of David Cassidy. Annie admits that she has never been on a plane before. Sam tells Annie that when he was a kid, he used to play in a box and pretend that he was on a rocket ship. He says that he would look at a magazine with a flight attendant on the cover and imagine that she would help him along during his travels.

The detectives find that, Lincoln, the man that Valerie was supposed to meet with, also took a flight with the first victim. Gene tells Sam and Ray that he has tickets for Annie's flight. At the airport, a pilot named Ronald flirts with Carol. He sees Valerie/Annie and tells her that he heard that she was attacked. Sam walks in dressed as a pilot. Leslie and Carol see Sam and tell Annie that he is cute. Annie says that she knows Sam. Sam meets with Ronald and tells him that his name is Tom Cruise. Ronald offers Tom a drink because he knows that he is hitching a ride. Ronald introduces Sam to Rita, his wife. The plane takes off and Annie sees that Ray is on board. Sam sees that Lincoln is on board. Later, Lincoln grabs Valerie/Annie and asks her if she has it. Annie tells him yes. Lincoln tells Valerie that he has been dreaming about it. Sam looks outside the window and sees the entire planet Earth in the distance. Lincoln gets up and tries to get under Annie's dress. Annie screams and fights him off. Ray runs to Lincoln, announces that he is police and arrests Lincoln. He tells the passengers that the plane is going to return to New York.