Later, Sheldon finds several teeth on the street. Stella sees a shoe print next to the initial splatter. She tells Sheldon that she thinks that someone stood the body up after he died. Stella sees blood on artwork made of trash bags next to the splatter. Sheldon says that he thinks that someone loaded the body into a car. They bring the trash bags to the lab. Stella tells Danny that a hand print on the bag is a mess. Danny says that he found a box cutter and sucrose at the scene.

Don tells Mac that the last person who entered the office before Dunbrook was a woman named Anne Steele. Mac remembers that Anne was a consultant that possessed a flash drive full of secrets and was murdered six months ago.

Stella and Sheldon discover a body dumped in the river. They see that the man has damage on his face that appears to be from the grate below Dunbrook's office. They see that the victim's fingertips have been cut off. Back at the lab, Sid says that he found strawberry candy on the victim with a fingerprint on it. Stella does a test and finds that the print was taken from Anne Steele. Stella tells Mac that he thinks that the victim obtained Anne's fingerprint and used a gelatin based candy to transfer it to a glove. She says that the victim probably used the glove to get into Dunbrook's office, then ate the candy. Mac learns that Anne used to work for Dunbrook.